Life story · Chapter 8 of 13

1936–1946

Party, Parliament and the Labour Ministry

From Annihilation of Caste to the Viceroy's Council

A seated portrait of Ambedkar as a lawyer. Commons dates it to between 1939 and 1942; the photographer is unknown.
A seated portrait of Ambedkar as a lawyer. Commons dates it to between 1939 and 1942; the photographer is unknown. — Photo: Unknown author · Public domain (PD-India) · Wikimedia Commons

By 1936 Dr. Ambedkar had spent years arguing for the rights of the “Depressed Classes”, the communities that the caste system treated as “untouchable”. In the next ten years he tried every tool he could find: a fierce pamphlet, a new political party, bills in the Bombay legislature, a strike, a seat in the British government of India, books and colleges. This chapter follows that decade. The making of the Constitution and his turn to Buddhism are told in other chapters.

A speech that was never given (1936)

In December 1935 the Jat-Pat-Todak Mandal of Lahore, a group of Hindu reformers working against caste, invited Dr. Ambedkar to preside over its yearly conference 1. When the organisers read his speech, they objected to his attack on the Hindu scriptures and to his statement that he would leave Hinduism. They asked him to cut those parts 2. He refused, the conference was cancelled, and on 15 May 1936 he published the speech himself as Annihilation of Caste 3 1.

Put simply, the speech makes three arguments. First, caste blocks every other kind of progress:

“turn in any direction you like, caste is the monster that crosses your path. You cannot have political reform, you cannot have economic reform, unless you kill this monster.”

— Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, Annihilation of Caste (1936) 4

Second, caste is not a brick wall but an idea: “Caste is a notion, it is a state of the mind.” Shared meals cannot end it. He calls inter-marriage the real remedy, then goes further: people will only change when they stop treating the scriptures that teach caste as sacred 5. Third, he offered a goal: “my ideal would be a society based on Liberty, Equality and Fraternity” 6.

The first 1,500 copies sold out within two months. The 1937 edition added his debate with Mahatma Gandhi, who had reviewed the speech in his paper Harijan 7 1.

Ambedkar with members of the Simon Commission, with Sir John Simon seen to his right, dated 23 October 1928 on Wikimedia Commons.
Ambedkar with members of the Simon Commission, with Sir John Simon seen to his right, dated 23 October 1928 on Wikimedia Commons.Photo: Unknown photographer (1928) · CC BY-SA 4.0 · Wikimedia Commons

A party for workers (1936–1937)

In August 1936 he founded the Independent Labour Party (ILP) to fight the first elections under the Government of India Act, 1935 1. He told The Times of India that he chose the word “labour” because labour included the Depressed Classes and others too. The party was open to people of every caste and creed 8. It promised land mortgage banks, new industries, limits on working hours, social insurance, free and compulsory primary education, and protection for tenants under the Khoti and Talukdari land systems 9.

In the 1937 Bombay elections the ILP contested 17 seats and won 15 1 10. By Dr. Ambedkar’s own count, that was 13 of the 15 seats reserved for Scheduled Castes in the province, plus 2 general seats 11. He himself sat for Bombay City (Byculla and Parel) 12.

Fighting for tenants and village servants

On 17 September 1937 he introduced two bills in the Bombay Legislative Assembly.

The first would abolish the Khoti system. In Ratnagiri and parts of Kolaba and Thana, the government collected land tax through landlords called khots, who were free to squeeze the farmers under them. His bill said these farmers had been “reduced to a state of abject slavery”. It proposed that the government deal with farmers directly, pay the khots limited compensation, and make the real tillers the legal holders of their land 13.

The second bill dealt with the Mahar watan. Under this hereditary system, Mahar families had to serve the village and the government in return for small plots of land and grain from farmers. The bill would let a family give up the service but keep the land by paying normal tax, and would make sure the remaining duties were defined and paid for 14. His collected works record both bills being introduced, but not passed.

He also took the fight to the streets. On 10 January 1938 he led peasants from Thana, Kolaba, Ratnagiri, Satara and Nasik to the Council Hall in Bombay, carrying posters reading “Down with the Khoti System” 15. In December 1939 he told a conference of Mahar watandars at Haregaon that the watan was “a system of heartless exploitation” 16.

Ambedkar with M. R. Jayakar and Tej Bahadur Sapru at Yerwada, Pune. The Commons description dates it 24 September 1932, the day Ambedkar signed the Poona Pact.
Ambedkar with M. R. Jayakar and Tej Bahadur Sapru at Yerwada, Pune. The Commons description dates it 24 September 1932, the day Ambedkar signed the Poona Pact.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain (PD-India) · Wikimedia Commons

The 1938 strike

In 1938 the Congress government of Bombay brought the Industrial Disputes Bill, which allowed jail terms for illegal strikes 10. Dr. Ambedkar argued that punishing a strike meant forcing people to work against their will:

“the right to strike is simply another name for the right to freedom.”

— Speech in the Bombay Legislative Assembly, 15 September 1938 17

On 7 November 1938 a one-day protest strike was held in Bombay. Dr. Ambedkar condemned police firing and lathi charges on the strikers and demanded a public inquiry. The government set up an inquiry committee 18 19.

Thinking aloud about Pakistan (1940 and 1945)

After the Muslim League demanded Pakistan in 1940, the ILP asked Dr. Ambedkar to study the question. His report became Thoughts on Pakistan (December 1940), enlarged in 1945 as Pakistan or the Partition of India 20 21.

The book lays out the Muslim case for Pakistan, the Hindu case against it, and the alternatives. In 1945 he gave his own view. If Muslims were truly determined to have Pakistan, “the wise course would be to concede the principle of it” 22. But borders should be redrawn so that non-Muslim areas were not forced in, and minorities should get safeguards or the choice to move 23. As he put it, “I prefer Freedom of India to the Unity of India” 24. He noted that the book upset both Hindus and Muslims 25.

Ambedkar with R. B. Srinivasan, G. A. Gawai and others after the Poona Pact, 1932.
Ambedkar with R. B. Srinivasan, G. A. Gawai and others after the Poona Pact, 1932.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain (PD-India) · Wikimedia Commons

The Scheduled Castes Federation (1942)

At a conference in Nagpur in July 1942, a resolution passed on 19 July founded the All India Scheduled Castes Federation (SCF) 26. Its constitution, as revised in 1955, lists its first aim as “to organise the Scheduled Castes of India” 27. It remained his main party until 1956.

Labour Member in the Viceroy’s Council (1942–1946)

On 20 July 1942 Dr. Ambedkar joined the Viceroy’s Executive Council, the British government’s cabinet in India, as Labour Member 28. A journalist wrote that no one from the Depressed Classes had held so high an office before 29. He also looked after the Central Public Works Department 30. That same year he criticised the Congress’s Quit India movement 31.

Talking across the table. On 7 August 1942 the government brought provincial governments, employers and workers together in a Tripartite Labour Conference. It became a permanent forum: the Indian Labour Conference and the Standing Labour Committee 32.

Shorter hours and paid holidays. In 1944 he moved a bill for holidays with pay for factory workers, which became the Factories (Amendment) Act, 1945 33 34. In November 1945 the Indian Labour Conference backed a 48-hour week. On 21 February 1946 he moved a bill cutting the legal week in year-round factories from 54 to 48 hours 35 36.

Welfare and wages. He amended the Mines Maternity Benefit Act in 1943 and 1945 37. He set up a welfare fund for coal miners (1944) and brought a bill for a similar fund for mica miners (1946) 38 39. In April 1946 he brought forward a Minimum Wages Bill and a bill requiring employers to write down workers’ service rules 40 41. Wartime dearness allowance (extra pay to cope with rising prices) was also debated. In 1943 he told critics that the government’s figures were not final 42.

Jobs and fair shares. By early 1945 employment exchanges were working in ten cities. A national resettlement and employment service followed for soldiers and war workers 43 44. Reserved posts for Scheduled Castes in central government recruitment rose from 8⅓ per cent (1943) to 12½ per cent (1946) 45 46.

Water and power. The Central Water Commission says it began in 1945 as the Central Waterways, Irrigation and Navigation Commission, set up on Dr. Ambedkar’s advice 47. He chaired conferences that turned the Damodar flood plan into a multi-purpose project for flood control, irrigation and electricity 48 49. He also chaired a meeting at Cuttack on Orissa’s rivers 50. In early 1946 he and Viceroy Wavell agreed to go ahead with the foundation stone of the Sambalpur dam, later known as Hirakud 51.

A hard choice. In 1943, during a wartime coal shortage, the government let women work underground in coal mines again. Dr. Ambedkar called it “a great misfortune” but defended it. Women legislators such as Renuka Ray attacked it, and the ban returned on 1 February 1946 52 53 54.

He urged India not to wait a century for labour laws, as Britain had:

“History is not always an example. More often it is a warning.”

— Address to the Indian Labour Conference, November 1945 55

His term ended when the Viceroy accepted the Council’s resignations on 24 August 1946 56.

An "Ambedkar Gate" put up by supporters of Ambedkar's Independent Labour Party in the late 1930s. (The Commons description gives the place as Delhi.)
An "Ambedkar Gate" put up by supporters of Ambedkar's Independent Labour Party in the late 1930s. (The Commons description gives the place as Delhi.)Photo: Unknown author · Public domain (PD-India) · Wikimedia Commons

Books as arguments (1945–1947)

  • What Congress and Gandhi Have Done to the Untouchables (June 1945) began as a study of the 1937 election results. It grew into a sharp critique of how Congress and Gandhi had handled the Untouchables’ demands 57.
  • Who Were the Shudras? (preface dated 10 October 1946) is dedicated to Jotiba Phule. It argues that the Shudras were once part of the Kshatriya (warrior) group and were pushed down after Brahmins refused them the sacred-thread ceremony 58.
  • States and Minorities (preface dated 15 March 1947) was written for the Federation to give to the Constituent Assembly. It is drafted as articles of a constitution: fundamental rights, minority rights, safeguards for Scheduled Castes, and state ownership of key industries and farmland 59 60.

Colleges of his own (1945–1946)

On 1 February 1945 he asked the Government of India for an interest-free loan of six lakh rupees to start a college in Bombay. He explained that Scheduled Caste students dropped out at the college stage because of poverty and unfair admissions. The college would be open to all castes 61. The People’s Education Society was established on 8 July 1945 62. Its first college, Siddharth College, opened on 20 June 1946 63 31.

Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Periyar E. V. Ramasamy and Ambedkar at Jinnah's residence in Bombay on 6 January 1940.
Muhammad Ali Jinnah, Periyar E. V. Ramasamy and Ambedkar at Jinnah's residence in Bombay on 6 January 1940.Photo: Unknown author · Public domain (PD-India) · Wikimedia Commons

1946: losing at the polls, finding a seat in Bengal

In the provincial elections of early 1946 the Congress won most seats reserved for Scheduled Castes, and the Federation did badly 64 65. Dr. Ambedkar argued that the “primary” rounds, where only Scheduled Caste voters voted, told another story. There the Congress got only 28 per cent of the votes 66.

Members of the new Constituent Assembly were chosen by the provincial assemblies in July 1946. Unable to win enough support in Bombay, Dr. Ambedkar was elected by the Bengal legislature 67 68. He depended on Federation activists in Bengal. Jogendranath Mandal, a Dalit leader from eastern Bengal, is widely credited with a big role in this 69. What he did in the Assembly is the subject of the Constitution chapter.

Where sources disagree

  • Working hours. Some articles say he cut the working day “from 14 to 8 hours” at a conference on 27 November 1942 10. His recorded speeches show something different. The cut was from 54 to 48 hours a week; the conference that backed it met on 26–28 November 1945; and the bill came in February 1946 70. A December 1945 letter from Viceroy Wavell speaks of a plan to go from 56 to 50 hours 71.
  • When he joined and left the Council. The King’s warrant is dated 9 July 1942, and he took office on 20 July 28. One article calls 20 July the warrant date 10. For his exit, the Columbia timeline says he resigned in June 1946 31, while a Viceroy’s House statement of 24 August 1946 accepts the Council members’ resignations 56.
  • 1937 seats. Most sources say 15 of 17 1. Congress publicity at the time said the ILP won only 12 of 151 reserved seats across India; Dr. Ambedkar called this a distortion 11.
  • Women in mines. Some tributes list “lifting the ban on women in mines” as a reform 10. In fact the 1943 decision let women work underground again, and it was widely criticised 53.
  • Federation’s 1946 seats. Exact figures differ. One account says it won 14 of 148 reserved seats 67; other accounts simply say it did badly 64.
  • The Bengal election. One historian dates it “late 1946” 68; another places it in July 1946 67. Who supplied his votes is also unclear. Raghavan only guesses that some may have come from Anglo-Indian, independent Dalit or Muslim League members.
  • SCF founding meeting. The BAWS editors give the Nagpur conference as both 17–20 and 18–20 July 1942 26.

Read more

Sources

  1. Columbia University – Pritchett timeline franpritchett.com ↗ ↩
  2. BAWS Vol. 1, pp. 29–31 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  3. BAWS Vol. 1, p. 28 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  4. BAWS Vol. 1, p. 47 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  5. BAWS Vol. 1, pp. 67–68 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  6. BAWS Vol. 1, p. 57 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  7. BAWS Vol. 1, p. 25 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  8. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, pp. 414–415 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  9. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, pp. 416–419 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  10. The Leaflet theleaflet.in ↗ ↩
  11. BAWS Vol. 9, preface p. iii Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  12. BAWS Vol. 2, p. 101 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  13. BAWS Vol. 2, pp. 96–103 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  14. BAWS Vol. 2, pp. 94–95 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  15. BAWS Vol. 17 Part III, p. 170 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  16. BAWS Vol. 17 Part III, pp. 213–214 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  17. BAWS Vol. 2, p. 208 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  18. BAWS Vol. 17 Part I, pp. 285–286 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  19. BAWS Vol. 17 Part III, p. 201 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  20. BAWS Vol. 8, pp. 5–6 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  21. BAWS Vol. 8, edition note Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  22. BAWS Vol. 8, p. 368 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  23. BAWS Vol. 8, pp. 379–380 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  24. BAWS Vol. 8, p. 367 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  25. BAWS Vol. 8, p. 2 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  26. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, p. 455 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  27. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, p. 457 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  28. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 10 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  29. Round Table India roundtableindia.co.in ↗ ↩
  30. BAWS Vol. 14 Part II, p. 1318 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  31. Columbia University – Pritchett timeline franpritchett.com ↗ ↩
  32. BAWS Vol. 10, pp. 100–102 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  33. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 201 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  34. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 292 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  35. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 299 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  36. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 326 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  37. BAWS Vol. 10, pp. 87, 274 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  38. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 137 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  39. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 373 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  40. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 1063 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  41. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 385 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  42. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 50 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  43. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 846 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  44. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 336 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  45. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 755 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  46. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 398 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  47. Central Water Commission cwc.gov.in ↗ ↩
  48. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 220 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  49. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 284 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  50. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 302 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  51. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, pp. 345–346 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  52. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 139 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  53. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 253 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  54. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 997 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  55. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 296 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  56. BAWS Vol. 10, p. 399 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  57. BAWS Vol. 9, preface Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  58. BAWS Vol. 7, preface Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  59. BAWS Vol. 1, pp. 383–385 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  60. BAWS Vol. 1, p. 408 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  61. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, pp. 423–428 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  62. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, p. 429 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  63. The Mooknayak en.themooknayak.com ↗ ↩
  64. The Caravan caravanmagazine.in ↗ ↩
  65. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, p. 226 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  66. BAWS Vol. 17 Part II, pp. 227–228 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  67. Law and Other Things – Vikram Raghavan lawandotherthings.com ↗ ↩
  68. Dwaipayan Sen, Cambridge University Press assets.cambridge.org ↗ ↩
  69. ThePrint theprint.in ↗ ↩
  70. BAWS Vol. 10, pp. 293, 299, 326 Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩
  71. BAWS Vol. 10, Transfer of Power extract Read this page on the site · Official PDF ↗ ↩

Key dates in this chapter

  1. Publishes Annihilation of Caste after the Lahore conference is cancelled source
  2. Founds the Independent Labour Party source
  3. Independent Labour Party wins 15 of the 17 seats it contests in the Bombay elections source
  4. Introduces bills to abolish the Khoti system and to reform the Mahar watan Writings & Speeches
  5. Leads a peasants' march to the Council Hall in Bombay Writings & Speeches
  6. Speaks against the Industrial Disputes Bill in the Bombay Assembly Writings & Speeches
  7. One-day protest strike in Bombay against the Bill Writings & Speeches
  8. Thoughts on Pakistan is published Writings & Speeches
  9. Resolution at Nagpur founds the All India Scheduled Castes Federation Writings & Speeches
  10. Joins the Viceroy's Executive Council as Labour Member Writings & Speeches
  11. First Tripartite Labour Conference meets in Delhi Writings & Speeches
  12. 8⅓ per cent of direct recruitment to central services reserved for Scheduled Castes Writings & Speeches
  13. Chairs the first Calcutta conference on developing the Damodar Valley Writings & Speeches
  14. Pakistan or the Partition of India (enlarged second edition) is published Writings & Speeches
  15. What Congress and Gandhi Have Done to the Untouchables is published Writings & Speeches
  16. People's Education Society is established Writings & Speeches
  17. Chairs the Cuttack conference on harnessing Orissa's rivers Writings & Speeches
  18. Indian Labour Conference backs a 48-hour week in factories Writings & Speeches
  19. Moves the Factories (Amendment) Bill to cut the week from 54 to 48 hours Writings & Speeches
  20. Reservation for Scheduled Castes in central services raised to 12½ per cent Writings & Speeches
  21. Siddharth College opens in Bombay source
  22. Elected to the Constituent Assembly by the Bengal legislature source
  23. Viceroy accepts the resignations of the Executive Council; his term as Labour Member ends Writings & Speeches
  24. Signs the preface of Who Were the Shudras? Writings & Speeches
  25. Signs the preface of States and Minorities Writings & Speeches
See the full timeline →
Cite this page

“Party, Parliament and the Labour Ministry: From Annihilation of Caste to the Viceroy's Council.” Prabuddha Pathak — Dr. B. R. Ambedkar, in his own words, prabuddhapathak.com. https://prabuddhapathak.com/life/politics/

Spotted a mistake or know a better source? Suggest a correction — it is recorded publicly on GitHub — or use the contribution form.